Sunrise vs. The Jazz Singer

 

Sunrise vs. The Jazz Singer

 

Sunrise vs. The Jazz Singer

 

Learn more about two sensational films which ushered in the Sound Film Revolution of the 1920s!

Return to 100th Anniversary Page

1927 can best be remembered as The Year of Sound Film. With the launch of the Movietone Newsreels and the sensation of Charles Lindbergh’s flight across the Atlantic in sound, the race to make a feature length sound film was on. In September, Fox Film Corporation debuted its first synchronized feature length film, Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans. Though popular with critics, it was quickly eclipsed in popularity a few weeks later by Warner Brothers’ The Jazz Singer. While neither film was the first to introduce audiences to sound, or even spoken dialogue in film, their popularity with critics and movie goers signaled the end of the Golden Era of Sound Film and the rise of Talking Pictures.

Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans

While Sunrise is commonly remembered by the film industry as a silent film, it was actually the first feature length film to employ a synchronized optical soundtrack. While there is no spoken dialogue between the characters, the film’s music score was provided entirely through the soundtrack. The film’s extensive fantasy set, mixed with artistic filmography, and a synchronized score made it a technical marvel of the time. The plot follows a farmer who is convinced by his lover to murder his wife, but in failing to do so rekindles their love.

Production Company

Fox Film Corporation

Director

F.W. Murnau

Debut

September 23, 1927

Sound System

Fox-Case Movietone

Awards

While critical reviews of the story were fairly mixed, the film won three Oscars in the first year of the Academy Awards in 1929.

  • Best Unique and Artistic Picture (a category which was only awarded the first year and was at the time considered as prestigious as Outstanding Picture)
  • Best Actress in a Leading Role – Janet Gaynor
  • Best Cinematography-Charles Rosher and Karl Struss

Legacy

Sunrise is remembered by film historians as a hallmark masterpiece of the Silent Era. While the synchronized score did not create the same sensation for sound film as The Jazz Singer or the earlier Lindbergh special, the ease with which the score was integrated (and the low expense of the system) foretold a future without movie theater organists.

The Jazz Singer

The Jazz Singer is best remembered for its combined two minutes of synchronized dialogue and music. The most significant moment in defining its popularity occurred when lead actor, Al Jolson, uttered his trademark line, “Wait a minute, wait a minute, you ain’t heard nothin’ yet” on the synchronized score. The vulnerability of maintaining the Vitaphone System was best revealed by the success of The Jazz Singer, as its successful implementation remained too complex and cumbersome to recreate its sound sensation outside of theaters in large cities which had already implemented the Vitaphone system. The film itself follows a Jewish musician defying the wishes of his father by becoming a jazz singer.

Production Company

Warner Brothers Pictures

Director

Alan Crosland

Debut

October 6, 1927

Sound System

Vitaphone

Awards

The Jazz Singer was largely excluded from the first Academy Awards as it was considered to have an unfair advantage to its competitors without sound dialogue. The film did receive an Academy Honorary Award.

Legacy

While neither the first to introduce audiences to sound dialogue or a synchronized score, The Jazz Singer proved to be an inspiration for the film industry outside of Warner Brothers and Fox Film Corporation to begin investing heavily in sound systems. While silent films would continue to be made years later, the building sensation and proven marketability of sound film led directly to The Talkie Revolution. The greater technical success of other film systems such as Movietone, however, led to the end of Vitaphone in 1928.

Thanks for Reading!

Crediting for Images on this Page

Image: Sunrise theatrical release poster, Public Domain, c. 1927 

Image: Promotional poster of Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans, c. 1927

Image: Poster for the movie The Jazz Singer , 1927. Warner Bros. (original rights holder)